|
KMID : 1234820210220020049
|
|
Korean Society of Law and Medicine
2021 Volume.22 No. 2 p.49 ~ p.79
|
|
|
A study on the Shift of Burden of Proof in Medical Malpractice ?Ruling of Jeonju Appellate Court 2017Na9346?
|
|
Lee Soo-Kyoung
Yoon Seok-Chan
|
|
|
Abstract
|
|
|
|
Due to defendant’s wrongful act by implant surgery, plaintiff has been suffered serious damages to his face and teeth, and pain caused by establishing implanted teeth. Jeonju Appellate Court sentenced to pay future medical expenses and alimony to the plaintiff in compensation for breach of duty or torts. The ruling is designed to relieve the burden of proof because it is extremely difficult for non-experts to determine whether dentists violated their ‘duty of care’ or whether there was a causal relationship between damages to medial treatment. It was judged that if symptoms that contributed to the patient's significant outcome occurred during or after surgery, such symptoms could be presumed to have been caused by medical negligence if indirect facts were proven to be other than medical negligence. Originally, the shifting of burden of proof in Germany, has already been developed in medical malpractice case since 1940s. In order to guarantee the patients’ right, §630h German Civil Code (BGB) - presumption of negligence in the realization of controllable risk- has been also legislated. BGH (Bundesgerichtshof) has been interested in ensuring that the principle of equality between patients and doctors. So, in this study, we wanted to refer to German precedent cases to analyzing Korean medical malpractice lawsuit. In particular, the decision could be significant in that it approaches closer to allows the shifting burden of proof in drastically growing dental malpractice cases. This is clearly confirmed in the judgment of the dentist’s “fault” that “if indirect facts about the symptom or occurrence are proven to be cause other than medical negligence, such symptoms can be presumed to be due to medical negligence.”
|
|
|
KEYWORD
|
|
|
Medical malpractice, Malpractice law suit, Burden of proof, Duty of care, Shifting burden of proof
|
|
|
FullTexts / Linksout information
|
|
|
|
|
|
Listed journal information
|
|
|
|